Why most startup JDs drive away great candidates

The best sales reps are employed and barely glancing at job boards. When they do look, they make a decision about your company in 30 seconds based on your job description. Most startup JDs are walls of requirements that read like a legal document. They lead with what you want from candidates rather than what you are offering them.

In a market like San Francisco or New York, where experienced GTM talent has ten options at any given moment, a generic, requirement-heavy JD is an automatic pass. You are not just competing with companies in your space. You are competing with every startup that posted a job this week.

Lead with the opportunity, not the requirements

Start with one paragraph that answers: what is the company, what is the market opportunity, and what will this person be building? Top candidates are evaluating your opportunity against 10 others. If your opening paragraph sounds like every other JD, they move on.

The best opening paragraph makes a specific, credible claim about why this role is worth leaving a good job for. That is the bar. Not "we are a fast-growing SaaS company", that describes every company posting on LinkedIn today.

Be specific about the role

State clearly: what is the territory or segment (SMB, mid-market, enterprise)? What is the ACV range? Is this inbound, outbound, or a mix? What does the sales cycle look like? How many AEs are on the team today?

This specificity signals that you know what you want, and it helps the right candidates self-select in. A rep who has spent three years selling $80K ACV deals to enterprise in Chicago does not want to discover on the first call that the role is actually $8K SMB in a high-volume motion. Save everyone the time.

Comp transparency wins

List the base range and OTE. Candidates who do not see comp listed assume it is below market. In 2026, comp transparency is the norm, hiding it signals you are either below market or disorganized. Include whether commission is uncapped. That detail alone will increase qualified applications.

Requirements: keep it honest

List 4–6 genuine requirements, not 12. Every requirement you add that is not real reduces your candidate pool. Ask yourself: would you reject a candidate who was exceptional in every other way but did not have this one thing? If not, remove it from the required list and put it in a "nice to have" section.

The most common error is listing years of experience as a requirement when what you actually care about is outcomes. "5+ years of SaaS sales experience" is a proxy for "has closed deals at our ACV." Say the thing you actually mean.

What to avoid

Avoid: "rockstar," "ninja," "hustle culture." These phrases signal a culture of performance theater rather than genuine results. The candidates you want find them off-putting.

"The test: would a great sales rep who is happily employed and has options read your JD and think 'I need to apply for this'? If not, rewrite the first paragraph."

Want help writing or reviewing your JD?

We have written hundreds of GTM job descriptions for startups across New York, San Francisco, Austin, and beyond. Book a call, we will review yours or help you write one from scratch.

Book a Free Call
15 minutes. No commitment. No pressure.
David Berk
David Berk
Founder & CEO, Beacon Talent